Soldiers was not a game I was familiar with, but I can see why it is so highly rated, despite it being more than forty years old.
The rules are clear and easy to grasp, and the scenario we played, Le Cateau, was a real wargamer's situation: British on defence, needing to find the best way to defend a wide front against a numerous and determined enemy; Germans on attack, needing to both exit companies from the opposite board edge and inflict a certain number of casualties to claim victory.
We got through two games, but only touched on the tactical possibilities available to both sides. It was an excellent choice of game for the day, and if the sangria led to some less than optimal decision making in the second game, it probably enhanced the simulation value of the exercise!
Here are a few of Pat's photos from the first game (during turn 1, and well prior to the sangria taking effect). I should note in passing that the photos do not do the map justice: it had a lovely antique look to it: there was nothing garish or overstated, and the whole effect was evocative but restful. It was a joy to play on.
Full board, from the German perspective |
Germans snake forward on the right. |
My British defending forward early, and getting battered for their troubles. |
As it turned out, the British won both games, but the first one in particular was very close indeed. There were a number of crucial actions which could have won or lost the game for either side, and we were both left thinking about different strategies to employ, which is surely one mark of a successful wargame.
On that note, while it was only a game for us, the huge slaughter depicted did give one pause for thought about how appalling it must have been for the poor chaps actually involved in these actions and others like them.
It's certainly a game I would play again.
Many thanks to Pat for a fine day's convivial play, and some excellent beverages!
Sounds like a great game!
ReplyDeleteThanks Ray! Well worth playing if you ever get the chance.
DeleteMakes me want to play it; the sign of a good review/replay. Thanks for sharing your experience with "Soldiers". http://www.grognard.com
ReplyDeleteThanks Mark, much appreciated!
DeleteI got a copy of Soldiers last year. I haven't played it yet, but I'm eager to. Every review I've read is strongly positive.
ReplyDeleteI hope you enjoy as much as I did when you finally do get it to table. Cheers!
DeleteOne of my favorites although I have not played in some time. 'Massacre of the innocents' being a scenario I tried and tried to win as the Germans, all the while noting how aptly named it was. Thanks for the memory.
ReplyDeleteloved this game, bought several extra sets of counters to make it even better
ReplyDeleteloved this game, bought several extra sets of counters to make it even better
ReplyDeleteI had the game back in the day. It would be interesting to see a revised edition published. This was one of the better SPI titles.
ReplyDeleteIIRC, one of the scenarios is Tsingtao (Japanese vs Germans 1914). I researched the OOBs awhile back in order to prepare a scenario for miniatures, and found the forces to be hopelessly unequal. Assuming my memory is correct (not a good assumption at my age), is the scenario for Soldiers playable?
ReplyDeleteBest regards,
Chris Johnson
Hi Chris, I'm not actually sure - the game does not belong to me! I'll ask my mate who owns it and get back to you.
DeleteCheers,
Aaron