Prufrock's Wargaming Blog

Prufrock's Wargaming Blog

Monday, July 2, 2012

Band of Brothers: day of days scenario.

This scenario sees six squads - including three reduced - of the 101st clearing a path through hedgerow country on June 6th, 1944.  To win the game the Americans must exit four squads off the eastern portion of the board.

The Germans have only four squads of their own, but their possessing an equal number of decoy markers means that the American player is faced with a race against time to find which areas are defended and which aren't, and to then exploit the gaps in the defensive line.  There are only five turns in this scenario, and as it takes three turns just to get from one end of the board to the other, there is no time to waste.

German set up:

The Germans deploy in two lines, and as this was a solo game I randomised the real and dummy units so that I (as the American player) would not know what I was facing.



Turn one:

The German defensive line looks forbidding - but there must be a way through!  The Americans enter from the western edge, moving into cover behind the hedgerows and firing in an attempt to suppress the enemy.


A lucky shot suppresses one forward position...


...which turns out to be a dummy marker.  There is an opening! 

The lone German defender on the right responds to the American advance with a burst of fire, but does no harm.

The forward squad on the left is given an opportunity fire marker to discourage the Americans from racing too precipitately down the road (opportunity fire markers give defenders a better chance of shooting up enemy squads which enter their line of sight).

The Americans elect to press on their right to see what they are facing there, but as they do not manage any suppression hits it turns out that they are none the wiser.


Time is ticking, so the last American squad elects to do a hail Mary move forward down the road and try to hit the remaining defender on the German right.   They move and cross the hedgerow but the Germans use their one command point (command points can be used to alter the normal turn sequence in particular ways) to attempt to activate their used unit and take a shot.  The units shoots and hits, in so doing losing its conceal marker.  The squad on opportunity fire duty now attempts to takes a shot of its own, but it does not react well to the pressure (it fails its proficiency test and cannot shoot.  On the positive side, this means that it retains its concealed marker).   The suppressed American squad fails its morale roll and stops in its tracks.

The Germans advance one of their rear squads to try to finish off the Americans, who hit the dirt, hold on to their helmets for dear life, and - for the moment - survive.


In the end of turn phase the forward American squad pulls back to the safety of the baseline, where it recovers to full morale.

Turn two:

The Americans try to suppress the squad facing their left, but have no success.  The Germans place Op Fire markers in return.  A shooting match ensues, which reveals the forward squad on the German left to be dummy.

The Americans now advance into the dead ground,taking a shot at the exposed flank of the German squad on the road.  Their shooting is deadly: the Germans take a casualty hit and are left fully suppressed.


The German rearguard now attempts to shoot at the advanced American unit but only succeed in revealing itself to be a dummy marker.  For the Americans, who now know where three of the enemy squads are, this is great news; but it is not so good for the Germans. 

There is sporadic shooting, but no more damage is done.

In the rout phase the German squad that took casualties retreats to safer ground and regains a level of morale in due course.



Turn three:

The Americans open up on the forward squad on the German right, inflicting casualties and a double suppression.  Seizing the moment, the Americans rush down the road, only for one unit to be suppressed by German opportunity fire. 

This latest firefight has revealed the position of the fourth German squad, which makes the American tactics fairly obvious from this point on.

Accordingly, the Americans on the far left take the chance to scamper past the disoriented Germans in the front line and outflank the rear squad (the fully suppressed Germans will only have a one in ten chance of being able to fire at the Yanks as they pass).  The Germans are in a panic and have no idea what to do as the squad sprints past them (they don't roll the 1 they need!).


Now in the German rear area, the plucky chaps open fire on the German squad overlooking the road, killing them all and clearing the roadway.  The units on the German left are already used, and are unable to effectively react to the resultant American advance.


Another burst of fire sees the last of the German right cut down by fire from behind.

The end of the turn obliges the last two German squads - which now have their flanks turned and positions exposed - to take a voluntary retreat towards the south edge of the board.

Turn four:

With the road east open, the Americans hie themselves off.  The Germans are unable or unwilling to do much about it (they fail their proficiency rolls and are unable to fire). 



Conclusion:

Thanks to a mixture of inexperience, bad luck, and the limitations of playing solitaire, the Germans managed to lose this one.  A real German player would been able to keep his squads hidden longer and thereby force the Americans to take more risks in manoeuvre to get their men east before time was up. 

I made what was in retrospect a bad decision in advancing the German second line squad on turn one to make a very low odds attack on the exposed Americans.  This saw them in a hex which, although protected frontally, was vulnerable to attack from  hex D3, and as the two German squads covering D3 turned out to be dummies, it left a gap in the line that the Americans were able to exploit to win the game.

The game was interesting and fast paced, and required some thought.  I'm still assimilating the rules and did not play optimally, but I'm starting to see how fire and movement fit together, how important correct use of terrain is, and the kinds of things I'm going to need to learn to do to play well.

This is the third time I've mucked around with this scenario, and when playing the attacker I'm going to have to get past my unwillingness to take risks with my men.  I've discovered that in this game I genuinely dislike exposing troops to unnecessary danger - why this is is perhaps an interesting question, if one for another time! - but clearly I'm going to have to get used to seeing friendly casualties if I'm going to be able to 'get the job done'.

As I come to understand it better, BoB is getting more interesting, and I haven't even got to the point of using MGs yet, much less mortars, bazooka teams, artillery, guns and armoured vehicles.  There's a lot more to get to grips with.  I'm looking forward to it!

Sunday, July 1, 2012

Thoughts on the hobby and my top ten wargaming books

One of the appealing things about wargaming as a hobby is that there are so many facets to it.  For starters, there is the purchase of figures, rules and boardgames, and the research that attends these activities.

As an aside, I don't know about others, but I can spend hours looking at figure lines and still come away without having come to a final decision on whether and in what quantity to buy.  If that is not in itself pathetic, knowing that I will come back and do it all over again three months later certainly is!

Then there is the late night painting or prepping of figures and the weekend modelling of terrain.  And when you are tired of dragging a brush over lead or plastic or cleaning up after experiments with flock, white glue and sheets of polystyrene, there is the reading and testing of rules to turn to, the checking of details online, the first tentative steps solitaire.

And there are still other interesting distractions: the writing and reading of blogs, discussions to follow on internet forums, the creation of rules, variants, scenarios and campaigns.  There are reviews and battle reports to compose, painting, washing and dipping methods to chronicle, opportunities to submit articles to hobby journals or games magazines, and for those of a more artistic bent there is also game-related photography to pursue.

In short, if you've had a gutsful of one thing or another, there is always something different you can turn to without needing to abandon the hobby altogether.  The chances are that concentrating on something else for a while will freshen you up, recharge the batteries, and perhaps provide a new idea or two.  If you've done as much painting as you can reasonably handle, it can be a fine thing to play a few games; if you have no clear and present enthusiasm for gaming, you can write a blog post, think about your next army, research figures, browse the internet forums or pick up a favourite book. 

In fact, even if other aspects of the hobby can temporarily lose their appeal, I find that the last mentioned, books, never do.  Whereas I can go for long stretches not wanting to look at a paintbrush or a prepping file, I visit the wargaming library at least once a day, and no matter how jaded I might be feeling there is always something there to spark my interest.

My library here is by no means extensive (most of my books are in New Zealand, unfortunately!), but there are ten books in particular that I find - for various reasons - to be essential.  So what follows is a list of those ten canonical texts.  These are the ones I'll pick up before bed, take on the train, put into the travel bag or smuggle into the toilet (that's right - don't borrow any of these books from me!).


- Armies of the Macedonian and Punic Wars, by Duncan Head.


This one is chockablock full of essential information for the ancients wargamer.  Army tidbits, tactical details, references to primary sources, battle overviews and - most useful of all - drawings and information on the various troop types wargamers need to know about and paint.  I don't know how I managed to get by without it for my first few years in the hobby.

Rome first met elephants when fighting Pyrrhos in Lucania, and these "Lucanian oxen" made a great impression at Heraclea.  Trying to work out how best to deal with them, Rome first experimented with gimmicks, like the wagons used at Asculum (see figure 180), squealing pigs, or incendiary javelins.  These were no great successes, the most effective weapon in the Pyrrhic wars being the javelin fire of the camp guards at Beneventum.  Regulus at Bagradas tried to meet the elephants' charge with a deep formation in the hope of standing up to it; this failed miserably.  Thereafter, Rome reverted to relying on javelinment, who wounded and picked the beasts.... (p.61)

- Lost Battles, by Philip Sabin.


As an ancients enthusiast I can pop this book open at any page and spend a profitable ten minutes reading around it.  It's usually a first port of call when I want to research a particular battle or think about rules issues.  As in indicator of just how tragic I am, I have three copies of this book situated in various strategic locations throughout the house and school.

Although Xenophon (Hell. VII.5.21-2) does emphasize how surprised and unprepared the allies were in the face of Epaminondas's advance, their established blocking position means that it is better to give them the first move as at Leuctra.  Epaminondas can then focus his attack where he chooses, and use his superior command to reach the centreline first while the allies are still coming back into their battle positions from the wood where Hammond suggests they may have been sheltering from the sun.  As at Leuctra, the Thebans concentrated against the ....  (p.123) 

- Wargames, by Donald Featherstone.


One of the first wargaming books I read when I got it from the library as a youngster.  I don't have Charge! or The Wargame (yet!), so this is a placeholder for the classics of that earlier era.  It was given to me by a friend, and out of respect for him this one does not go into the toilet with me, just in case he ever wants it back!

It must be confessed that the question of how to fight a successful action with natives against disciplined troops has yet to be completely solved by the writer.  One method allows the natives to move a longer distance than the troops, or to time the moves and have the disciplined troops on movement trays so that they can move as one whilst the natives move individually in a rabble.  Another means lies in having low morale ratings for natives when the situation arises that the morale of both or either is in question.  A compromise can lie in having....  (p.59)

Honourable mention for Scenarios for Wargamers, also by the Don.

- A Guide to Wargaming, by George Gush with Andrew Finch.


I found this in a second hand shop in New Zealand a few years ago and it was a score.  It contains a history of wargaming, numerous sets of rules, and a discussion of approaches to game design that are still relevant today.  If I had thirty minutes to evacuate the house this is one book I'd save.

A New Era

Reverting to the miniatures game, the next 'great leap forward' undoubtedly came on a Saturday evening in summer 1957, when Southamption physiotherapist Don Featherstone read an article in his local paper about a certain Tony Bath, a local wargamer unable to find an opponent.  Don had played games based on Little Wars as a boy before the Second World War.  He now, on impulse, fixed a meeting with Tony....  (p.31)

- Armies and Enemies of Imperial Rome, by Phil Barker.


As with Duncan Head's book, this one is filled with very useful information about the period and its actors.  Again, the real gems are the illustrations and notes on troop types.

44, 45, 46 and 47.  Roman Infantry Officers

Up to the 1st century A.D., Centuriones may have been dressed and armed pretty much like their men except for their crest and greaves, but there is no definite evidence to confirm this.  From then on, they seem to have been allowed some latitude in dress and armour, as a number of different outfits are depicted on monuments.  Alternatively, this may represent differing regimental practices.  (p.77-78)

Honourable mentions also for Armies and Enemies of the Crusades and Armies of the Dark Ages, by Ian Heath, and also published by WRG.

- The DBM army lists, by Phil Barker and Richard Bodley Scott.


First-class resource for information about armies.  If I'm thinking about beginning a new army this is the first place I turn to.  You get proportions of troops, an potted history of the army and a good starting point for further research.
    
This list covers the period of the initial revolt against the Seleucids until the death of John Hyrcanus.  The varied classification of the guerillas reflects the initial difficulty in obtaining an adequate supply of weapons, and the rapid shrinking of the army from 3,000 to 800 men on sighting the enemy at Elasa, contrasted with a generally high state of morale fostered by religious enthusiasm.  The course of other later battles implies the presence of more solid troops.... (Book 2, p.39)

Honourable mention to other army lists such as those of Field of Glory, Armati, DBA, Warmaster Ancients, Warhammer Ancient Battles and Hail Caesar.  None of them quite compare to these though, to my mind.

- Ancient and Medieval Wargaming, by Neil Thomas.


This is another modern classic that harks back to the golden age of wargames publishing.  Containing simple rules modified for different periods, army lists, battle reports and information about figures, it is a good starting point for those new to the hobby or for veterans who like to take rules sets apart and put them back together again after their own fashion.

With the onset of turn 6, the stunned Saxon general had more decisions to make.  Having just eliminated its opponents, one of the Saxon nobles (unit 2) had three options.  Firstly, it could head for the edge of the table, and exit on turn 7.  This option was rejected on the basis that to do so would expose its flank to cavalry assault....   (p.193)


- The Gallic War and The Civil War, by Caesar.


While these were not written specifically for wargamers, we could be forgiven a certain solipsistic conceit, as it's impossible to go two pages without finding something of immediate import for an ancient wargamer.  It's not an exaggeration to say that every time I pick up Caesar I find something else I would like to underline, highlight, or shout about on some internet forum.  Absolutely essential.

But the Roman citizens quickly defended themselves by constructing wooden towers, and since their resistance was weak because of their lack of numbers, and they were enfeebled by the many wounds they suffered, as a last resort they set free all the adult male slaves, and cut of the hair of all the women to make artillery.  (The Civil War, III.9)

Honourable mentions go to Arrian, Appian, Polybius, Livy, Herodotus, Xenophon and Thucydides.

- Simulating War, by Philip Sabin.


The newest book on the list is likely to be regarded in future as a classic of the genre.  If you want to learn more about studying and designing wargames, this is excellent.  It contains a nice mix of theory and practice, and includes eight simulation games that illustrate some of the principles Phil Sabin espouses.

The drawbacks of a simple combat resolution system such as the one I have just outlined are that its outcomes are rather unidimensional, it can involved lots of die rolling and it often embodies the same unrealistic assumptions as in Lanchester's flawed model (which the system here would mirror faithfully if continued over several turns of fighting).  Hence, most wargame designers instead construct one or more 'combat results tables' (CRTs) to streamline resolution procedures and to give them the flexibility to....  (p.93) 

Honourable mention goes to Board Wargaming, by Nicholas Palmer.


- Warfare in the Classical World, by John Warry.


An illustrated history of classical warfare that is good as a surprisingly detailed overview of the period.  I don't always agree with all its conclusions, but it is a very useful resource despite that.  It has plenty of information about particular campaigns, tactics and equipment which have proved of great help at various times.

Punicus is the Latin for "Carthaginian".  The first Punic War was provoked by those perennial troublemakers the Mamertines who, based on Messana (Messina), appealed to the Carthaginians against Hiero II, the Greek king of Syracuse.  Their object achieved, the Mamertines wished to be rid of the Carthaginian garrison which had protected them, and they appealed to Rome.  (p.114) 





So, there we have them: the ten most essential books in my wargaming collection.  I'd be interested to hear what readers' top wargaming books are, so please feel free to talk about yours in the comments section - and many thanks if you made it this far!

Friday, June 29, 2012

A magnificent gift from my lovely wife!

It was a welcome surprise during a particularly hot and humid afternoon at work today to have a box filled with boutique beer arrive! 

My wife had ordered them for me as a Father's Day gift.  What a woman!

So here they are - nicely chilled - and I'm trying to decide which one to open.



I think we'll go with this:







Cheers, all!


Thursday, June 28, 2012

Commands and Colors: Ancients Solitaire variant.

Reading Bob Cordery of (amongst other things) Wargaming Miscellany's fame's blog post on playing Memoir '44 solo reminded me of a solitaire variant I used to use to play Commands and Colors: Ancients.

The idea was initially inspired by something another fellow had posted (I think it was this, yet can't remember for sure), but I changed it around quite a lot and gave the non-player side certain advantages in the hope that it would become a more challenging 'me versus AI' type of game.  It is of course perfectly possible to play Commands and Colors games by drawing cards as normal and simply playing both sides, but as I do that with Lost Battles I found that I wanted something a little different.

The point of difference in these rules was that the 'AI' did not use the same card deck as me - it used a 'virtual deck', which divided the cards into seven types: left, right, centre, flank, leadership, special and troop.

The 'Virtual Deck'

The non-player turn consisted of me choosing the best three to five cards still in the virtual deck -with certain restrictions in place - and rolling a d10 to see which of the cards would get played.



The number of cards in the select pool depended on morale, which degraded as the non-player army took losses.  The higher the losses the greater the number of cards and the smaller the chance that the AI would get the cards that would be most effective. 



When a card was used it would be crossed off the virtual deck and could not be used again until a 'reshuffle' had occurred, at which point the deck would be reset.  A reshuffle would be caused by the play of 'I am Spartacus' by the player side, or by the virtual player not being able to make a legal card selection.


And that's about it.  I recall that I played about five games of Arausio with it, losing three out of five. In the end I decided it wasn't worth all the extra record keeping, so if I were to revisit it I think I would make or buy a second set of cards to use for the non-player hand to cut out the bookwork.

I would use this second deck to provide the selection pool for the non-player side, using twice as many cards as were officially in the non-player's hand with modifications as seemed sensible.  From that draw 3-5 cards would be selected, and I would most likely relax the restrictions on card types able to be selected.  The card used would be removed from the deck but the others would be put back in and the deck reshuffled.

This would make for less record keeping but at the cost of increasing the amount of shuffling.

So, there we have it.  Any and all comments and questions most welcome!

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Worthington Games' Band of Brothers: Screaming Eagles

Band of Brothers: Screaming Eagles by Jim Krohn was the second game I picked up on our recent excursion to Tokyo.

BoB:SE is a squad level WWII game focusing on the 101st Airborne from Normandy to the Battle of the Bulge.  Counters represent squads of 10-15 men, a weapons team, an individual gun and its crew or an armoured vehicle.  Ground scale is, so far as I can gather, around 40 yards to the hex, with a turn representing 2-3 minutes of real time.

There are five double-sided geomorphic maps, done in the style of the old Commando comics.  I quite like this, though I believe it rankles with some.


The counters are large and attractive, but while the game contains two counter sheets, half a sheet's worth of them are blank!  The ones that actually are counters do however look very good set up.  The pictures below do not show a real scenario but should give you some idea of the overall effect...



  
Also included are 16 historical scenarios that vary in size from one map to five, a quick reference card, and a rulebook, containing some excellent designer's notes.

The rules are for the most part clear, but there are a couple of errata issues caused by typos.  I had no trouble skimming through them quickly and starting a game immediately.

The lot:


So far I've found it very enjoyable solo, even though it's really meant to be a two-player game.  It's simple enough to pick up and quite straightforward in play, but still seems to require skill and reasonably historical tactics (to my untrained eye!) to play well.  It was ridiculously expensive in the game shop I got it from, but I think it's going to be worth it.  After all, an expensive game that gets play is much better than any number of cheaper ones that don't!

Work calls me right at this moment but I will be back with some more thoughts on rules and a game report or two as time allows.

( Here is a link to a report of the first scenario, day of days ).


Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Battles Magazine #8

Well, look what just arrived in the letterbox today.  It really is a beautiful magazine; its only fault is that this edition contains a small article by yours truly, complete with a bonus comma in its introductory paragraph!  As they say, I wouldn't subscribe to any magazine that would have me as a contributor...    


Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Warmaster Ancients test game

To my great delight I recently managed to pick up a copy of the Warmaster Ancients rules from wargame buddy John, who was selling off a few bits and pieces.  I'd been wanting to get a hold of this set for ages but  kept getting sidetracked with other things and other purchases (as I tend to do...), but I have it now and decided to test it out on Sun/Mon on the big table at school.

I set up a 1000 point Roman/Carthaginian game, set somewhere in Spain, with a hill and a couple of small groves for terrain.

I didn't go overboard with pre-studying the rules; I just set up as I saw fit and then played through a few turns solo to see how things would go.  Veteran players will no doubt see some egregious errors in my deployment schemes here; everyone else will be able to get a giggle at the base of velites who didn't know whether they were coming or going...


Things kicked off with a determined Roman advance in the center, aiming to get to grips before the Carthaginians could get too much done on the flanks.  Unfortunately, command rolls prevented much cohesion, and while the central block advanced without problems the flanks trod forward rather more gingerly.

Carthage was able to secure the copses on the right and infiltrate light infantry into positions suitable for harassing the flanks of the Roman infantry advance.


The centre, meantime, shortened their lines to meet the more compact Roman formation.



Third turn in things were still progressing very slowly, mainly due to horrific command rolls.  The Spanish light infantry gained the hill, but a command blunder saw the Numidians impetuously charge a unit of velites.  In the ensuing scrum they were pushed back by a hail of javelins before getting to grips properly, but in thsie own shooting phase forced the Romans to scurry back to safety behind their heavy cavalry. 

I thought the interactions worked well.


The skirmishers gain the hill.

Roman advance
Numidian stand off...
As time was running out I hurriedly - and with utter disregard for the rules - drew the sides together to test out how melee combat worked.  It was bloody, but seemed to work OK.


So, points to note:

1) Skirmishers are quite effective in that they are able to drive back would-be attackers and disrupt the line.  I think these will be fun to use in a proper game.  Horse will be needed to counter their evade ability, and light horse especially.

2) It's a lot harder to move units than I'm used to from games such as Lost Battles.  The threat of imminent command failure makes you weigh up priorities.  While poor command dice are very bad, they can turn good very quickly, so there will be big swings in fortune that will always offer a chance to come back from all but the very worst positions.

3) Hand-to-hand combat looks to be bloody.  Keeping reserves on hand and finding the right way to get them into the battle line will likely be key elements in game play.

4) I like how the table looks.  The lines are nice and clean, but have a shape to them that I miss when using the zones in Lost Battles.

All up, I'm very pleased.  I think these will be a fun set of rules and there is plenty of potential to add in extra rules here and there as well.  I can see some similarities to Commands and Colors: Ancients (particularly in the way skirmishers operate, and the way that retreats and pursuits work), and think it will likely reward similar skills.

Now the only problem will be to find someone prepared to play it with me!
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...