Cannae concludes

On turn six the Carthaginians began by using the cavalry to attack the Roman rear.

The Gauls score one hit on the Roman centre...

and Hasdrubal muffs his chance.

But the Numidians atone for their reluctance last turn by shattering Varro's guard.

Things look very ominous for Rome.

The morale die is cast with the army at -3: -1 or four or more units shattered; -1 for two or more uninspired generals withdrawn; -1 for having enemy to front and rear.

But these are legionaries.  They get a +1 for being heavy infantry, and a further by reason of their virtus.  A high morale roll will see them through.

But it doesn't come - for the second time in the battle they roll a one, and the entire force streams off the field!

And so it comes time to tally the results.

The Romans start with a fighting value of 70 compared to the Carthaginians' 84, so they have a handicap of 42.  They have left eleven average quality Carthaginians units and one veteran spent, which adds 37 points to their tally.  They total 79 points.

The Romans have fled early, which is a mixed blessing.  Carthage has scored only five shatters, for a total of 30 points, but the Carthaginians have not suffered any themselves.  They can add another 30 points from routed units and 21 from units withdrawn (withdrawn units being fresh units who rout in sympathy).

So the victory points stand at 79 for Rome and 81 for Carthage, giving Hannibal a very tight victory.  If Rome had scored just one more hit during the battle, the points victory would have gone the other way.

This game is yet another mark in favour of Phil Sabin's excellent handicap system, which gives both sides a good chance of victory, even though in the field battle the odds may be stacked.

While there were a number of key moments in the game, the timing of Carthage's success was always slightly ahead of the 'battlefield clock', and this allowed enough depresssion of Roman morale to cause a rout before the fragile Carthaginian front began to fold under pressure.  But as the point results show, it was very close.  Ifs indeed!

It was a great game, and after a long time between (lost) battles, it has proved a timely reminder of the gaming I've been missing.

Cannae carries on...

Turn four begins with Hasdrubal charging into the waiting triarii.  He has the advantage of momentum and numbers, but if he cannot break though now then the triarii will hit back hard, and may even shatter a unit.  He therefore decides to lead the attack himself, and puts everything into it.

... and the dice are kind.  The double hit shatters the triarii and there is nothing left to oppose Hasdrubal's advance.

Despite the great mass of the legions appearing to still be in fine fighting fettle, the Roman rear is now vulnerable.

On the right, the Numidians take their turn.

After the three hits they scored with their mightily effective skirmishing, Varro's wing is also in trouble.

It has been a decisive turn for Carthage, and as the heavy cavalry envelop the infantry line it is hard to see how Rome can come back from this.  The only thing in their favour is that - the Roman right aside - the infantry is still in pretty good shape.  The question is, if they can break through, will it be in time?

So Varro leads off with urgency and scores a hit on the Numidians, who are now all spent.  If Varro can survive the counter attack and score another hit next turn, it might be enough to put the Numidians to flight and go some way towards turning the tide.

The legionaries now get into their work, and as they grind their way forward they begin to inflict some serious damage.

Five hits by the Romans this turn have brought them back, but they will need staunch defense next turn and will require a breakthrough soon - in  Hannibal's zone if at all possible, as it is all spent bar one unit of Gauls.

Rome's success is dependent on ifs; Carthage's on whens.

Turn five sees Carthage drive in on the Roman right.  The appearance of the Carthaginian veteran infantry from behind the Gallic host incites panic.  They score a hit, and on a morale roll of one rout the remainder of the wing.

The heavy cavalry continues its advance, even going so far as to fall in behind Varro's cavalry.

But the infantry attacks are ineffective and most of the Romans still in the line are fresh.

On its own turn Rome attacks first in the centre, scoring one more hit.  It is not enough to force a shatter in Hannibal's zone, but his units there are now all spent, so he will have to make a decision next turn on whether to stand - risking heavy losses and personal injury - or to fall back and give up his key zone.

Varro makes another gallant attack, but the dice speak for themselves...

And so, at the end of turn five, the Romans have lost four units shattered and another four to rout, with Paulus among them.  Surely they cannot last much longer?

The Grail Arrives...

Look what's just come thundering down the pike!

I've been hunting for this for a long time, and I'm going to get a lot of enjoyment out of it.  Many thanks to Tom S - auttiecat on TMP - who hooked me up.

Cannae continues

In the breaks in the cricket, Cannae continues from the earlier post...   Here Hasdrubal unleashes the Gallic cavalry who immediately score a double hit, destroying the equites opposing them and opening up the flank.

The infantry skirmish in the centre without doing any damage, but the rest of the Gauls advance into contact.

Hannibal now declares his flip flop* and moves again.  He can only mount attacks from the zones he didn't attack from in the previous turn, but these each score two hits on the ends of the Roman infantry line.  The heavy cavalry of Hasdrubal's wing continues its advance until halted by the triarii.

On the Carthaginian right the Numidian light cavalry holds back to avoid allowing the Roman infantry to extend the line.

In their turn the Romans turn the triarii to meet the threat and these score a hit, knocking Hasdrubal's Gauls off their stride.  If they can hold for another turn they may be able to do some real damage to the Carthaginian cause.

On the left Varro accepts the inevitable and charges the Numidians.  Despite the negative modifiers for charging at distance, a hit is scored.

The infantry score another hit on the right...

And one more on the left.

The Romans appear to have absorbed the worst of the flip-flop attacks and are hitting back well.

* For those unfamiliar with Lost Battles terminology, a flip-flop turn allows a 'brilliant' general to reverse the turn order, effectively allowing an exploitation turn.  Attacks cannot be made from the same zone in two successive turns, so flip flops are usually used to attack after moving into contact or after making a breakthrough.

Cannae commences...

I've got a solo game of Cannae on the go using Lost Battles.  I'm not making much progress (due mainly to cricketing distractions), but here are a couple of shots of the 'historical' deployment anyway.

And after the Romans' first turn, in which they score a couple of hits on the enemy and advance the infantry, while - in a nod to hindsight - leaving one unit of triarii to react to any potential cavalry breakthrough.